| Movie Title | Theirs | Your Rating | Overall | Add |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| El Dorado (1967) | 4.0/4 | 2.9/4 | ||
| Silverado | 4.0/4 | 2.8/4 | ||
| Big Jake | 3.5/4 | 2.9/4 | ||
| Pat Garrett and Billy the Kid | 3.0/4 | 2.9/4 | ||
| Viva Villa! | 1.5/4 | 2.6/4 | ||
| Barbarosa (1982) | 2.0/4 | 2.7/4 | ||
| McLintock! | 2.5/4 | 3.0/4 | ||
| 3:10 to Yuma (1957) | 3.0/4 | 3.0/4 | ||
| The Proposition (2005) | 4.0/4 | 2.8/4 | ||
| Open Range | 4.0/4 | 2.9/4 | ||
| Broken Trail | 3.0/4 | 2.8/4 | ||
| The Ox-Bow Incident | 3.0/4 | 3.1/4 | ||
| Young Guns (1988) | 4.0/4 | 2.8/4 | ||
| Pale Rider | 4.0/4 | 2.9/4 | ||
| The Sons of Katie Elder | 3.0/4 | 3.0/4 | ||
| Union Pacific | 3.0/4 | 3.0/4 | ||
| The Shootist | 3.5/4 | 3.0/4 | ||
| Shane | 3.5/4 | 3.1/4 | ||
| The Assassination of Jesse James by the Coward Robert Ford | 1.5/4 | 2.9/4 | ||
| Stagecoach (1939) | 4.0/4 | 3.1/4 | ||
| True Grit (1969) | 4.0/4 | 3.0/4 | ||
| Gunman's Walk | 3.5/4 | 2.8/4 | ||
| Lonesome Dove | 4.0/4 | 3.1/4 | ||
| Red River (1948) | 4.0/4 | 3.1/4 | ||
| The Cowboys (1972) | 4.0/4 | 3.0/4 |
